It’s banned books week

the loraxEach year, I stray from my usual environmental topics at the end of September to talk about The American Library Association’s Banned Books Week. We’re in the middle of BBW right now – it’s always the last week of September.

Did you know that at one time a school system attempted to ban The Lorax? In 1989, the Laytonville, CA Unified School District challenged the book based on someone’s belief that it criminalized the foresting industry. Ridiculous, right?

I wrote about this last year on Sustainablog, and I thought I’d share what I wrote with you here.

What does book banning have to do with sustainability. A whole lot.

Many times people want to ban books that scare them. Or they want to ban books that go against their agenda. Or they want to ban books that contradict their religious beliefs.

This environmental movement that is going on right now, and must continue to go on, scares many people, goes against many people’s agendas, and unbelievably goes against some people’s religious beliefs.

At its very heart, book banning is about muffling free speech. Books are one of free speech’s most powerful allies. Once something is published in a book, it has an enormous ability to influence. The only way to stop it’s influence is to get rid of the book.

Spoken word is powerful, too, of course. And with the today’s technology, it’s easy to record and preserve the spoken word, but for most of our history, it has been the written word that has recorded people’s thoughts and ideas and preserved them for others to chew on.

What if the chemical industry had been successful in its efforts to ban Rachel Carson’s 1962 Silent Spring, the book that many consider the catalyst of the modern environmental movement?

What if The Lorax wasn’t available for me to read to my sons? It’s such a gentle introduction for children to taking care of the earth and also a powerful inspiration to adults.

What if my sixth grade teacher hadn’t been allowed to read my class A Wrinkle in Time by Madeleine L’Engle (a book that has been challenged many, many times) and my eyes hadn’t been open by Ms. L’Engle’s words to the greater world around me?

When I think about the answers to these “what if’s,” I realize that I need to take a stance against book banning, as an environmentalist and as person who believes in everyone’s right to think, say, and write what they believe, even if I disagree with them vehemently.

My other reason for writing about this is that many people may think that the only books that get challenged today are those about having two mommies or The Harry Potter Series. But it’s not so. Today on one of Green Option’s other blogs, Eco Child’s Play, Jennifer Lance wrote about the fact that some people want to ban author Mem Fox’s children’s books, not because of their content, but because Ms. Fox said something they didn’t like about childcare.

How dangerous is that? Banning someone’s books because of her opinion!

We environmentalists have a lot of opinions. What if someone tried to ban our writings because they didn’t like them? Or our opinions scared them or went against their religious beliefs?

Banned Books Week is a reminder that we have the right to say what we want to say and write what we want to write. We should never allow anyone to take that away from us, and we should never try to take that away from anyone else.

Take a look at this list of books that have been banned or challenged though out the years and find one that you want read. Then read it.

I leave you with this cartoon from the fabulous Debbie Ridpath Ohi’s Inkygirl blog that she generously allows to be used under a creative commons license.

banned books comic

  1. So many great books in that banned list! I think my favorite has to be To Kill a Mockingbird.

    I even heard yesterday that there had been an attempt to ban Everyone Poops. It’s such a funny book and kids totally love it. If you’re not familiar with it, here is a video from ALA which mentions it http://alfocus.ala.org/videos/banned-books-week-puppet-book-banners

    It so happens I sell it, in case anyone just has to have a copy http://www.myubam.com/ecommerce/details.asp?sid=L2441&gid=86833707&emkt=156&title=Everyone+Poops&sqlwhere=submit%3Dsearch%26search%3Dpoop
    Feel free to remove that little plug for my book business if it is inappropriate.

    • robin
    • September 30th, 2009

    To Kill A Mockingbird is an amazing book that EVERYONE should read. I used to teach it to my 10th grade English students and I don’t recall a kid who didn’t really like it. No matter how much they would moan when they saw the length of the book when I handed it out, they were fans by the end.

  2. Oops, my bad. I’m not sure that Everyone Poops is/was a banned book. What I can tell you though is that some Usborne Books and More consultants refuse to offer books they don’t personally approve of to their customers. I’ve been told they put “not available” stickers on their catalogs.

  3. I have read and re-read Maya Angelou’s “I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings” over the years and I’m grateful that I’ve had that opportunity. I just wish fewer folks would read Ann Coulter……Thanks for a great article.

  4. GREAT post, Robin!! Book banning is so amazing to me. It is 2009, right?! It also speaks to larger issues of control and trying to teach kids what to think vs how to think. So much fear out there, and a lot of it is fear you won’t agree with me, so I will attempt to squash that before it happens. The importance of critical thinking skills are never more evident than when we see situations like book banning.

    Standing with you. Cheers- Bethe @balmeras

  1. No trackbacks yet.